Reminder Secure

copy cat yes or no

Samantha Duell is off-line
13 February 2014 16:33
SDuell
Photographer
SDuell
Location
United Kingdom
Cambridgeshire
whittlesey

so i recently saw a load of images by a photographer who did a shoot involving a lake and the model getting all muddy

now would it be wrong to try and do a simular shoot cause i really liked the idea and the images were really good i wouldnt do the exact same thing i would put my own spin on the idea


have you ever seen images and thought id like to try that?

or think thats a really good idea wonder if i could do that?

or would you be really annoyied someone tryied to copy your work?

or would you think it was a compliment someone admired your images and wanted to have a go


im not one to copy cat peoples ideas but i really really liked it and admired the model for getting so dirty in this cold weather

you thoughts?


13 February 2014 19:31
PaulManuell
Photographer


Hello Sam. I'd say go for it. Obviously don't just recreate an exact copy, just follow the idea but put your own spin on it. And personally speaking, I'd be flattered, not annoyed, if someone wanted to recreate a photo I'd taken.


Profile Pictures is off-line
14 February 2014 03:46
profilepictures
Photographer
profilepictures
Location
United Kingdom
Suffolk
Bury St Edmunds

Nothing is new, its all been done before, never set out to copy but accept everything you've seen becomes a reference to you.

But no, don't go out to copy, take a theme and try to make it yours, and better.


Chrissie Red is off-line
14 February 2014 03:46
Chrissie_Red
Model
Chrissie_Red
Location
United Kingdom
Tayside
Perthshire

Chances are they wouldn't even notice, I've done about 20 shoots in a lake getting all muddy and none of them looked all that similar.
Different clothing/lighting conditions/photography styles and location all play their part.

I've seen many images which inspire me, I'm sure most people have and its ok to take inspiration from elsewhere - its normal. I would only be annoyed if it was something really really similar - Like if I had a really unusual pose, a teapot on my head and a cat on my shoulder if somebody did exactly that  - only then I would think "hold on thats really quite Chrissie_Red is a naughty person ty". Thankfully its only happened a few times but it has annoyed me a little. I find it better to take elements from other shoots - if I like the styling I will do something similar but in a totally different location with different style of photographer etc.

I remember going to a location and doing a nude shoot, I uploaded the images to my blog then a couple of days later I was on another photographers blog, he had taken a model to the same location (months before I had my shoot there) and the model was doing almost the same pose in the exact same spot. I quickly deleted my shots and they have never been put on any of my portfolios - out of respect. It was a complete coincidence that myself and another model chose the same spot to pose and similar poses - I guess thats what happens when you take a model into a dark abandoned building and they find the light then use the interior to pose against. It happens but I would have hated the original model and photographer to think I had directly went out to copy them.





Bill_M is off-line
14 February 2014 04:44
Bill_M
Photographer

Location
United Kingdom
Lanarkshire


There is no copyright on ideas. Also, you can be almost sure that the photographer whose work you saw got the idea from someone else. As long as you don't try to make your work an exact copy of his there is no problem.


OldMaster is off-line
14 February 2014 04:48
OldMaster
Photographer
OldMaster
Location
United Kingdom
Hertfordshire
Harpenden

We are all motivated by what we see and as has been said there is nothing new! Anyway plagiarism is a form of flattery.

What you are saying is you have been inspired by another's work but your location, model and setting will probably be different as will your style..just do it!


Len Maynard is off-line
14 February 2014 07:31
Skid2
Photographer
Skid2
Location
United Kingdom
Cheshire
Stockport

Go for it and put your own mark on the session.

It will never be the same as the original but the new images will be your ideas inspired by someone else with the model adding her input to your ideas

Best of luck and enjoy.
"I never cared for fashion much, amusing little seams and witty little pleats: it was the girls I liked." - David Bailey


David is off-lineGold Member
15 February 2014 16:58
david1500
Photographer
david1500
Location
United Kingdom
Tyne and Wear
Gateshead


If you create a new style you are going to be very rich , just have fun and enjoy yourself .


22 February 2014 06:27
stevephot
Photographer


If you think that there is much originality in photography you will be very mistaken.

Whether is card board boxes on peoples heads, or a particular pose, or heavily dodged and burnt images...whatever it is, i can assure that it had been done by the 1930s

There is nothing wrong with plagiarism, its a great way to improve your own photography.
Dont blame me..i voted for the other lot :)


RGBphoto is off-lineSilver Member
22 February 2014 07:20
magpie1
Photographer

Location
United Kingdom
Tyne and Wear
Newcastle

Plagiarism is pinching all your ideas from 1 place, pinching them from multiple sources is called research! Virtually every theme has been done but if that was the controlling criteria then we'd all have to stop doing anything! Copying established images was long considered essential in painting study, observing technique and process, then people absorb and adapt, producing new variations on a theme.

Should be a good learning experience, give it a go.



32 Users currently online   Blue=Models Orange=Photographers Red=Agencies Purple=MUA/Stylists Grey=Studios Green=Moderators
bonni_cuffs ElleLaura kacie QueenDeeVa01 RoxyMendez skykantara1
ad360photo antoinewynn asnphotography Bane711 BOBREEVES Cheshunt83 dave2008 davejohn ellessephotography fineprint hylander IanHighlander Ianparker1 jasper Jpdo jyp Kjoservices liteangle moritz78 oscar pmeswani Swyftie thelook Thestarglider tms tonyjolley