No comments, its a bit of a shame.

No comments, its a bit of a shame.

14 posts
31 Jan 2015
profilepictures
Photographer
profilepictures
Not wanting to see a mutual preening and ego polishing exercise as is popular elsewhere... But its become uncommon for anyone to pass a positive or appreciative comment on photographs here it seems. I notice as I try not to do so unless I feel its justified, but often notice a picture which is really good or creative that's apparently unrecognised?

Seems a bit of a shame to me.

PS naturally I'm excluding the saddo comments which we can still do without.

Posted 31 Jan 2015
marlhamphoto
Photographer
marlhamphoto
I must admit I don't comment very often. And I do feel guilty about that as I receive a few from other people. But like you, when I do comment it's because I genuinely appreciate the image. Or perhaps if I see something that doesn't quite hit the mark but the effort is apparent and I'd like to give some encouragement.

Posted 31 Jan 2015
magpie1
Photographer
magpie1
Agree, it is a pity, I have also commented similarly, before, and do try to give a comment to images I like (including one of yours, recently!) so without an excess of stunning awesomeness, it is good if we aren't too reticent of commenting on what we think are good images.


Posted 31 Jan 2015
swalsh58
Photographer
swalsh58
Perhaps it would be simpler if there was a 'like' button like on FB? You could show that you liked an image without making a comment. Many comments that are left are inappropriate or just plain wrong. The comments that wind me up are those like 'stunning' and 'great concept' usually on very average images. The ones that p**s me off totally are those from so called photographers who say things like 'awesome bum!' which is hardly professional, no matter how awesome it is! I suppose you have to draw a line somewhere between a really great subject, and a really great photograph. The subject may be great, but the photographers technique and composition poor, or a poor choice of subject, but excellent photography skills.

Posted 31 Jan 2015
mph
Photographer
mph
swalsh58

Perhaps it would be simpler if there was a 'like' button like on FB?


Or "Love" - symbolized by a heart icon?  wink

Posted 31 Jan 2015
I agree. It's very quiet here on the comments, encouragement and positivity side of things.

Posted 1 Feb 2015
Stibnite
Photographer
Stibnite
I have the header images turned off so its not easy to get the image feed, so I guess I dont see much uploaded that makes me want to go and comment.

Posted 1 Feb 2015
mph
Photographer
mph
ArtemisFauna

I agree. It's very quiet here ..........................




Posted 1 Feb 2015
BigEarsPix
Photographer
BigEarsPix
swalsh58

Many comments that are left are inappropriate or just plain wrong. The comments that wind me up are those like 'stunning' and 'great concept' usually on very average images. The ones that p**s me off totally are those from so called photographers who say things like 'awesome bum!' which is hardly professional, no matter how awesome it is!


Agree, comments are a waste of time.
Posted 8 Feb 2015
BigEarsPix

Agree, comments are a waste of time.


But then again so is life

As Keith Lemon once said 'Life is what you do until you die'

(some of these 'facts' might not be correct, sorry)
Posted 8 Feb 2015
BigEarsPix
Photographer
BigEarsPix
clearview_photography

But then again so is life

As Keith Lemon once said 'Life is what you do until you die'

(some of these 'facts' might not be correct, sorry)


If you are talking about my life I must agree.

Who?

I can not accept your apology. smiley

Posted 8 Feb 2015
w4pictures
Photographer
w4pictures
Comments aren't a waste of time.

There's a world of difference between the "nice arse" comments and the ones that affirm the success of both photography and modelling.

Posted 8 Feb 2015
SMILESPHOTO
Photographer
SMILESPHOTO
Agree with the above, although all image comments are purely subjective in just the same way as 'nice arse' type comments are. All beauty (and talent) are in the eye of the beholder - viz. Tracy Emin's unmade bed.

Posted 9 Feb 2015
Mr_Catz
Photographer
Mr_Catz

If any image catches my eye, then I most probably will comment on it. I don't tend to look at who the model is or who the photographer is that has taken the image.

The reason why I mentioned this is because I've noticed on other sites that certain photographers will comment on other certain photographers but not others. I also notice that some popular models get large amounts of praise for their work even when it's, well, quite frankly, awful. The bad photography is not the model's fault. She still has to put it out there to let paying photographers know that she is  available.


By the way, I agree with the "Like" idea.
Posted 14 Feb 2015
Edited by Mr_Catz 14 Feb 2015
To reply to this thread you must be a member. Click here to join