See Also This Consolidated Feedback Guideline ~ G14 ~§~ The Feedback System ~§~ This site's administrators try to provide a simple and easily manageable Feedback system to allow members to both recommend good Models / Photographers / MUAs and to record when members let down other members.
Unfortunately the efforts of a minority to either buck the system or encourage others to misuse or circumvent this simple process are putting the system in severe jeopardy and it might be withdrawn completely.
Many of the "white knights" and many of those those suggesting "fixes" seem not to have much of a clue just how difficult it is even to run the current system nor do they realise how many will lie, cheat, bully and cast aspersions in their quest to have legitimate negative feedback removed.
Often when the "white knights" jump in to defend the honour of models (an action which in itself can be a dubious tactic used to influence the naive) without having seen BOTH sides of the story they are being counter-productive.
If anyone has a genuine grievance over feedback please go through the Report process giving Moderators the full facts and allowing them sufficient time to investigate. And when they make a decision please just accept it and move on.
Likewise if anyone thinks they have a more workable Feedback concept which is fair, infallible and not overly costly and labour-intensive to operate feel free to suggest it through theContact uslink rather than arguing in forums.
It is NOT the end of the world if you receive a blue icon but it could be the end of the Feedback system if members don't accept that sometimes they might deserve one
Leaving a No-Show report when no shoot was actually booked is unacceptable.
Leaving a No-Show report when the other member cancelled with fair notice is unacceptable.
Leaving a Negative Recommendation just because someone does not wish to shoot is unacceptable.
Trying to ruin the reputation of another member after being left a Negative Recommendation is
unacceptable and brazenly lying to the Moderator & Administrator Team is unacceptable.
If members do not use the Feedback / Recommendations responsibly they risk losing the facility.
Note that verification and arbitration of feedback disputes can be near impossible
if members take communications off-site and/or do not use the Shoot Diary and Internal Mail