Reminder Secure

Wide aperture plus strong light?

Nick Edinburgh is off-lineSilver Member
11 August 2012 06:06
Nick_Edinburgh
Photographer
Nick_Edinburgh
Location
United Kingdom
Edinburgh
Edinburgh

Excuse my stupidity, but I can't see a good solution. I was shooting last weekend in bright sunlight, using fairly powerful portable flash to overpower the ambient light. But at the same time I'd like to be opening up the aperture fully, for max bokeh. The problem of course is that even on the lowest ISO it's going to be over-exposed. Is there any solution, other than using an ND filter?

BTW, I was using Nikon D800 with f1.8 85mm lens, with Ranger Quadra lights.

-- 

Oh, and I'm sure this has been answered a thousand times before, but how the heck do you include an example image from disk in a new topic posting like this?


Steven Jardine is off-linePlatinum Member
11 August 2012 06:20
RedChecker
Photographer
RedChecker
Location
United Kingdom
Buckinghamshire
Stoke Mandeville

California Sunbounce do a rather clever piece of equipment called a Sun-Scrim which you could use between the model and background:
http://www.sunbounce.com/sun-scrim-20-x-20-screen-no-moire-black

Additionaly you can use their Sun-Cage to remove ambient light around the model:
http://www.sunbounce.com/cage-fabric-no-frames



Failing that, get yourself a MF body with leaf-shutter lenses. The latest Mamiya has built-in Profoto Air-Sync which when used with Profoto flash they are good for up to 1/1600th at ISO 50 IIRC
If you can't dazzle 'em with brilliance, baffle 'em with bullshit


Hugh is online
11 August 2012 06:33
Hugh
Photographer
Hugh
Location
United Kingdom
Dyfed
Aberystwyth

Cheaper options...

1)

shoot film in a MF body with a leaf shutter lens - syncs up to 1/500.

Yashicamat 124G for £100

or there's a very nice Bronica ETRSi setup listed in the for sale forum here at the moment for a little more.


2)
Experiment with a compact - something like a Canon G11 - effortless fill-in flash - bokeh isn't so good, but you could help it along in Photoshop.
It's not Fine Art just because it's in Black and White.


Matt Harper is off-line
11 August 2012 06:35
mattharper
Photographer
mattharper
Location
United Kingdom
Devon
Paignton

The only way I can see of overcoming this is with High Speed Synch flash, which I doubt you can achieve with portable flash units.

My green hedge in the garden is well lit by sun now and at f2 on 100 ISO, the camera says it needs to shoot at 1/2000th of a second.

My best advice would be ditch the flash and try using a reflector to light subject. You have said it was bright sunlight. This way, you can use whatever shutter speed you like. The issue you might have then is bright light in the subject's face and they may be fighting not to squint so positioning the reflector(s) is important.

If necessary, two reflectors, but you will no doubt need an assistant. With the products Redchecker recommends, you would need two or three assistants and a bloody good bank balance.

Shooting on location brings enough problems without having to set up a cage or scrim, not to mention the money.

I think my Lastolite reflector was about £70, but you can actually make your own.

Sometimes, it isn't about throwing money at a problem, there are other ways.



Steven Jardine is off-linePlatinum Member
11 August 2012 06:40
RedChecker
Photographer
RedChecker
Location
United Kingdom
Buckinghamshire
Stoke Mandeville

If you can afford Pocket Wizard's TTL flash trigger system they have a feature called Hypersync which can work in two ways with large/studio flash units:

1 - you can fine tune your normal sync speed to be increased by up to a stop (depending on camera, flash used etc.)

2 - you can use Hypersync to take a 'slice' of the flash duration from the flash, admittedly this is not using the full amount of flash power but when your shutter speed is in the thousandths of a second it may just do the trick.
If you can't dazzle 'em with brilliance, baffle 'em with bullshit


Hugh is online
11 August 2012 07:00
Hugh
Photographer
Hugh
Location
United Kingdom
Dyfed
Aberystwyth

Buy a D70s just for outdoor flash use. I'd get one if I shot nikon.
Shuter syncs at all speeds because it switches off the chip instead of narrowing the shutter aperture for faster speeds.

http://strobist.blogspot.co.uk/2011/12/q-controlling-sun-when-using-flash.html
http://strobist.blogspot.co.uk/2008/01/control-your-world-with-ultra-high-sync.html
http://strobist.blogspot.co.uk/2011/03/nikons-d7000-sync-dial-goes-to-eleven.html
It's not Fine Art just because it's in Black and White.


Hugh is online
11 August 2012 07:00
Hugh
Photographer
Hugh
Location
United Kingdom
Dyfed
Aberystwyth

Buy a D70s just for outdoor flash use. I'd get one if I shot nikon.
Shuter syncs at all speeds because it switches off the chip instead of narrowing the shutter aperture for faster speeds.

http://strobist.blogspot.co.uk/2011/12/q-controlling-sun-when-using-flash.html
http://strobist.blogspot.co.uk/2008/01/control-your-world-with-ultra-high-sync.html
http://strobist.blogspot.co.uk/2011/03/nikons-d7000-sync-dial-goes-to-eleven.html
It's not Fine Art just because it's in Black and White.


Nick Edinburgh is off-lineSilver Member
11 August 2012 07:00
Nick_Edinburgh
Photographer
Nick_Edinburgh
Location
United Kingdom
Edinburgh
Edinburgh

Thanks! That's all really helpful food for thought to consider my options.

Just as an afterthought, to those of bigger brains who understand such things... I can kind of naively understand why it's a fundamental technical challenge for camera manufacturers to push the high end of ISO without too much noise. (There just ain't enough photons hitting the sensor to work with.) But I find it harder to see why they can't more easily push the low end further. Do the sensors themselves have a basic physical limit to how much light they can cope with before the signal degrades in some other way?


Steven Jardine is off-linePlatinum Member
11 August 2012 07:04
RedChecker
Photographer
RedChecker
Location
United Kingdom
Buckinghamshire
Stoke Mandeville

Quote from Nick_Edinburgh
 But I find it harder to see why they can't more easily push the low end further.



I'd like to know this also.  Plenty of times I'd have given an arm and a leg for an ISO of 25 or 12
If you can't dazzle 'em with brilliance, baffle 'em with bullshit


" Hibby " is off-lineSilver Member
11 August 2012 07:14
BrazenDivas
Photographer
BrazenDivas
Location
United Kingdom
Highland
Inverness

Quote from Hugh
Buy a D70s just for outdoor flash use. I'd get one if I shot nikon.
Shuter syncs at all speeds because it switches off the chip instead of narrowing the shutter aperture for faster speeds.





Does this apply to the slightly earlier D70 Hugh?
"A technically perfect photograph can be the worlds most boring picture" Andreas Feininger



115 Users currently online   Blue=Models Orange=Photographers Red=Agencies Purple=MUA/Stylists Grey=Studios Green=Moderators
Agneska20 amyhamilton21 Axelle azura_sky bazbow Cathyduck1969 DianaB dirtyjohn511 djk1511 Eeeve EliciaSolis Emmarachael Haileylou ivoryflame jennykiss69 jodunn32 KimStone kittiwara luciejuice100 maevis1988 missloulou MrsManson nightshade pipster ravenstorm28 RedHotChilliPepper Roomorgue Rugar Sazelle ShellieMarie sinderellarockafellA softgentle sophierobertsonnn tansy_blue toniallcorn weepee19 xxtinkerbell86xx
alexkidd Andy_B aspn27 Bane711 basil benarrivo27 bigphilphotography bopguy2k8 brendan BustyBritain carpe_diem chicimages Chr154bes claude Curved_Creations Dave@studio99 denyerec eclipsephoto Ellemme epsmith fastpixphotography Flash follyhouse fragiled Gerry99111 glamshots Gordoncburns grahamr hk500 Hugh Incubus11 jackcalling john80 just_lez Ken_Smith krissb Ladiesman lensfoto limholmes lxstuart mantisphoto Martin_D_Jones MartW modelimaging Mrlove1990 nigel onster owenter paul_j Paul_Tooth pdons74 peter1969uk pippins profit pvfb rdimages rembrandt ron sbglamour scporter Sev sgps ShackledMaidens simpleharmonicmotion sirspread spencerdixey Spsphotography stav969 Steve_Stanford SteveSJS55 Stolenfaces take5 Tklr2002 Webbo2 Weldrake59 womble xxlysonsxx yekim